Skip to content

Agent Regression Evals — prove the change did not make it worse

Engineering - POWERFUL agent-regression-evals Source

Install: claude /plugin install engineering-advanced-skills

Portability: 3 stdlib scripts, no APIs, no LLM calls. You run the agent; these grade, count and gate.

"Pass rate went from 82% to 79%" is not a finding until you know whether three points is outside the noise. Agents are non-deterministic, so one trial per case cannot tell a regression from a coin flip, and a final answer can be right while the path to it called a tool it never should have.

Workflow

# 0 - Run every case k times (k >= 3) on baseline and candidate, from a clean
#     environment per trial. Write one JSONL row per trial:
#     {"case_id": "refund-lookup", "trial": 1, "passed": true, "critical": true,
#      "cost_usd": 0.012, "trajectory": [{"tool": "get_order", "args": {...}}]}
# 1 - Grade the path where the path matters (safety, required lookups).
python scripts/trajectory_checker.py --spec cases.json --results candidate.jsonl
# 2 - Separate flaky cases from stable ones before trusting any comparison.
python scripts/flake_detector.py --results candidate.jsonl --k 3 --quarantine-out q.json
# 3 - Gate: paired per-case comparison against baseline. Exit 4 blocks the merge.
python scripts/regression_gate.py --baseline baseline.jsonl --candidate candidate.jsonl --quarantine q.json

Step 1 uses match modes strict | unordered | subset | superset. Default to superset (required steps present, harmless exploration allowed); grade the outcome, not the path, unless order is the requirement. forbidden tools block in every mode.

Step 2 reports pass@k (succeeds at least once in k) and pass^k (succeeds all k times). A user meets every trial, so pass^k is the reliability number. Cases marked critical are never quarantine candidates.

Step 3 averages trials within each case first (trials of one case are correlated), then tests paired per-case differences with a t-based 95% CI and a one-sided exact McNemar test. When the drop is real but the sample is too small to show it, the gate says how many cases it would take.

The gate blocks on

  1. A statistically significant drop (CI upper bound below zero, or McNemar p < 0.05).
  2. A critical case that passed every baseline trial and failed any candidate trial.
  3. A baseline case missing from the candidate run. Dropping a case is the cheapest fake fix.
  4. A quarantine entry with no owner or expiry, or covering a critical case.
  5. A forbidden tool call (trajectory checker, exit 4).

It warns, and a human decides, on an underpowered drop above --tolerance or a cost rise above --max-cost-increase.

Hard rules

  • Never compare single trials. Under 3 trials per case the flake detector refuses (exit 4).
  • Never pool trials as independent samples. Average per case, then compare cases.
  • Never quarantine without owner and expiry. An expired entry re-enters the gate automatically.
  • Never delete a failing case to go green. The gate counts what is missing.
  • Never call "no significant drop" a pass on 8 cases. Report the power note with the verdict.
  • Start the suite from real failures (20-50 cases), balanced between "should do" and "should not do".

Scripts

Script Role Exit codes
scripts/trajectory_checker.py Grades tool-call paths: match modes, args modes, forbidden tools, call ceilings 0 · 2 deviations · 3 bad input · 4 forbidden tool
scripts/flake_detector.py STABLE_PASS / STABLE_FAIL / FLAKY per case, Wilson CI, pass@k, pass^k, quarantine stubs 0 · 2 flaky · 3 · 4 too few trials
scripts/regression_gate.py Paired CI, exact McNemar, critical cases, dropped cases, quarantine validity, cost 0 PASS · 2 WARN · 3 · 4 BLOCK

All support --sample and --output json.

References and assets